Skip to main content

GPT-6.2 Astra vs Gemini 4 Carbon: Benchmarks, Cost, and a Hands-On Test

We compare GPT-6.2 Astra and Gemini 4 Carbon on benchmarks, cost per task, and a hands-on test where each model composes and performs a piano piece.
Josef Waples
Josef Waples

Create Your Free Account

Practice and track your progress.

Continue with GoogleBy continuing, you accept our Terms of Use, our Privacy Policy and that your data is stored in the USA.

Google released Gemini 4 Carbon at the end of October, and it topped the Artificial Analysis Intelligence Index at launch. Three weeks later, yesterday, OpenAI answered with GPT-6.2 Astra, and its launch charts put Carbon next to Astra on five benchmarks.

So is GPT-6.2 Astra better than Gemini 4 Carbon? On those shared benchmarks, slightly, and usually for less money per task, even though Carbon costs a quarter as much per token. There is, however, also a gap in speed, and our hands-on test (see below) made that speed gap hard to miss.

To keep up with the AI and data space, I recommend subscribing to our weekly newsletter, The Median.

TL;DR

  • GPT-6.2 Astra edges Gemini 4 Carbon on four of five benchmarks the two share, none by more than 3.1 points.
  • Carbon costs a quarter as much per token, but it uses far more tokens, so it often costs more per task.
  • In our piano test, Astra built a working page on all six tries, each in minutes; Carbon managed two of five and took 12 to 34 minutes for those.
  • Choose Astra for professional deliverables, coding, and fast, high-volume work.
  • Choose Carbon for cybersecurity, very long documents, and Google Cloud deployments.

What Is GPT-6.2 Astra?

GPT-6.2 Astra is OpenAI's frontier model, released on November 17, 2026, as the top tier of the GPT-6.2 family, above GPT-6.2 Sol.

OpenAI pitches it on professional output at a lower cost per task: documents, spreadsheets, and slides that follow your templates, plus stronger science, coding, and computer-use results. Our GPT-6 Astra API tutorial is a good way to practice using the API. 

What Is Gemini 4 Carbon?

Gemini 4 Carbon is Google DeepMind's strongest model, released on October 28, 2026, two weeks after Gemini 4 Argon, on which it is based.

Google pitches it on cybersecurity and long-horizon work: finding, exploiting, and patching vulnerabilities, and engineering tasks that run for hours or days. It first went to cyber defenders through Google's Fairwind Program and is now in the paid tier of the Gemini API. To practice with the API, we put together a Gemini 4 Carbon API tutorial that builds an agent that audits a fraud model.

GPT-6.2 Astra vs Gemini 4 Carbon: Head-to-Head Comparison

GPT-6.2 Astra vs Gemini 4 Carbon benchmarks: Astra leads four of five shared benchmarks, none by more than 3.1 points; Carbon leads AutomationBench

On the benchmarks both models appear in, the race is close: Astra leads four of five, but no gap is bigger than 3.1 points. The bigger differences are cost per task, speed, and the specialties each vendor reports on its own.

FeatureGPT-6.2 AstraGemini 4 Carbon
DeveloperOpenAIGoogle DeepMind
ReleasedNovember 17, 2026October 28, 2026
Token prices4x Carbon's (2x from December 1)A quarter of Astra's, introductory
Cost per taskLower on 3 of 4 OpenAI charts1.6x to 2.6x Astra's on those 3
Professional workSlightly aheadSlightly behind; leads AutomationBench
Agentic codingAhead on FrontierCode 2.0Behind by 3.1 points
Cybersecurity and long contextClose behind on SEC-bench Pro; no long-context scoreGoogle's headline strengths
Our hands-on testWorked 6 of 6 times, in 2 to 7 minutesWorked 2 of 5 times, in 12 to 34 minutes

Pricing: what you actually pay

On paper, Carbon is the bargain: during its introductory period, every rate Google publishes is a quarter of Astra's. But two things narrow that gap.

Token rates side by side

RateGPT-6.2 AstraGemini 4 Carbon (through November 30)Gemini 4 Carbon (from December 1)
Input, per 1M tokens$8.00$2.00$4.00
Output, per 1M tokens$40.00$10.00$20.00
Cached input, per 1M tokens$0.40$0.1095% off input

The first catch is the calendar: Carbon's prices double on December 1, 2026, which, as of writing this, isn't very far away, leaving Astra's token rates at twice Carbon's rather than four times. The second is that Google bills Carbon's thinking tokens as output, and Carbon reasons for much longer.

What a real workload costs

Worked at list rates as (volume ÷ 1M) × rate, summed across input and output, for a balanced assistant handling 1M input and 250K output tokens a month:

ScenarioGPT-6.2 AstraGemini 4 Carbon
Same token counts, Carbon's introductory price$18.00$4.50
Same token counts, Carbon's price from December 1$18.00$9.00
Carbon writes 3x the output tokens, from December 1$18.00$19.00

The last row is the realistic one for reasoning-heavy work. On OpenAI's GDPval v2 chart, Carbon wrote 108,729 output tokens per task at high effort, against 35,812 for Astra at its maximum, about 3 times as many.

Why the same task can cost more on Carbon

Cost per task: Gemini 4 Carbon costs 1.6x to 2.6x as much as GPT-6.2 Astra on three of four OpenAI charts despite lower token prices

OpenAI's launch charts plot cost per task for both models, and Astra is cheaper on three of the four: Carbon costs 1.6x as much on Agents' Last Exam ($4.60 against $2.89), 1.9x on the Intelligence Index, and 2.6x on AutomationBench. FrontierCode 2.0 is the exception, where Carbon's best run cost 14% less than Astra's.

These are OpenAI's measurements of a competitor, so treat them as a direction rather than a quote. Artificial Analysis points the same way on time: it measured about 29 minutes per task for Carbon at medium effort, against 1.5 minutes for Astra at low.

Professional work and agentic workflows

Astra leads this dimension by a hair: it is ahead on Agents' Last Exam and GDPval v2, while Carbon wins AutomationBench by 1.5 points.

Scores below come from OpenAI's launch charts, at each model's best-scoring effort.

BenchmarkWhat it measuresGPT-6.2 AstraGemini 4 Carbon
Agents' Last Exam v1.1Long, multistep professional workflows78.3%77.4%
GDPval v2Real consulting, finance, and design assignments50.4%48.8%
AutomationBench 1.0.6Automating business workflows52.4%53.9%

The gaps are small enough that cost and speed should decide it, and both favor Astra.

Agentic coding

Astra is the stronger coder on the one coding benchmark both appear in: 44.2% on FrontierCode 2.0, which grades whether code changes are good enough to merge, against 41.1% for Carbon.

BenchmarkWhat it measuresGPT-6.2 AstraGemini 4 Carbon
FrontierCode 2.0Code changes good enough to merge44.2%41.1%
Terminal-Bench 4.0Agentic tasks in a terminalNot published65.2%
SecureSWEWriting functional, secure code65.7%Not published

Google's own table compares Carbon with the older GPT-6 Astra, not GPT-6.2, so its coding wins there don't carry over. Its WebDev Arena rank, fourth with 1,768 Elo, shows Carbon is a capable web developer.

Cybersecurity, long context, and reasoning

This is where Google concentrates its claims, and mostly where OpenAI has no matching numbers for GPT-6.2 Astra. The one overlap is SEC-bench Pro, where OpenAI's system card puts Astra at 86.75%, 1.45 points behind Carbon, though each vendor ran its own test.

BenchmarkWhat it measuresGPT-6.2 AstraGemini 4 Carbon
SEC-bench ProFinding and reproducing software vulnerabilities86.75%88.2%
ExploitGymExploiting vulnerabilitiesNot published54.8%
CWE-benchPatching vulnerabilitiesNot published71.0%
GraphWalks (256K to 1M tokens)Reasoning over very long inputsNot published96.2%
Artificial Analysis Intelligence Index v5.0.1A composite of 9 evaluations (index score, not %)62.160.0

On Google's own table, Carbon beats the previous GPT-6 Astra on all three security benchmarks and leads GraphWalks by 24 points. OpenAI reports its own security results for GPT-6.2 Astra, such as 79.7% on PatchBench, but on benchmarks Google doesn't use.

For security work and very long inputs, Carbon has the stronger published evidence; on the broad reasoning composite, Astra is 2.1 points ahead.

How GPT-6.2 Astra and Gemini 4 Carbon Performed

Benchmarks from one vendor about a rival only go so far, so I gave both models the same creative coding brief: build a single web page that composes a beautiful, original solo piano piece of 60 to 90 seconds and performs it as falling notes. Colored bars drop toward an on-screen keyboard, and each note has to sound the moment its bar reaches the keys.

That brief is hard in two ways that are easy to check. The music has to be a real piece, with a melody, harmony, and an ending, and the sound has to stay in time with the picture. The models also had to work blind: they can't hear or see the page, so it has to work the first time, with the piano sound synthesized in the browser rather than played from recordings.

Both ran in OpenCode with the same tools and the same prompt, and I gave each model three attempts at each effort level. I started both at high reasoning effort, which is Carbon's top setting and the middle of Astra's five.

What happened at high effort

GPT-6.2 Astra built a working page on all three attempts, each in about 6 to 7 minutes and for $1.00 to $1.27. Each piece ran 73 to 76 seconds, and each page played with no errors.

Gemini 4 Carbon produced no page at high effort. On one attempt, it reasoned for 40,881 tokens and then ran into its 65,536-token limit for a single response while still writing the file, so nothing was saved. On another, the provider dropped the connection after 18 minutes and the attempt ran out of time; a third was cut off when my laptop went to sleep, so I don't count it.

That fits Google's own model card, which warns that Carbon "may use more tokens to maximize performance, especially at higher thinking levels," and that there "may also be occasional slowness or timeout issues."

What happened at medium effort

So I ran both models again at medium effort. Carbon built two working pages out of three, in 34 and 12.5 minutes, for $1.09 and $0.83. Its third attempt lost the provider connection twice and ran out of time after an hour.

Astra built a page on all three medium attempts, each in under 3 minutes and for $0.36 to $0.43.

Here's GPT-6.2 Astra's page, playing its piece "Between Tides" (turn your sound on):

Between Tides

And Gemini 4 Carbon's:

Lanterns on Still Water

What I noticed:

  • The two models designed very different pages. Astra built a framed listening room with the piece's title, key, and tempo, and left- and right-hand notes in two colors over a landscape. Carbon went full screen with an 88-key keyboard and glowing bars, closer to the falling-notes videos people learn songs from.
  • Carbon's two pages share a title. Both are called "Lanterns on Still Water" and are in the same key, E-flat major, while Astra gave its six pieces six different titles.
  • I preferred Astra's "Between Tides." I'm not a musician and can't say exactly why. It is built like a real piece, in four named parts, from "First light" to "Homeward."
MeasureGPT-6.2 Astra (high)GPT-6.2 Astra (medium)Gemini 4 Carbon (high)Gemini 4 Carbon (medium)
Working pages3 of 33 of 30 of 22 of 3
Time per attempt6 to 7 minutes2 to 2.5 minutes29 to 30 minutes, no page12.5 and 34 minutes; third timed out at 60
Cost per attempt (USD)$1.00 to $1.27$0.36 to $0.43$0.01 and $1.34$0.83 and $1.09; $0.01 for the third
Length of the piece73 to 76 seconds74 to 77 secondsNone72 and 77 seconds

At medium effort, Carbon's working attempts cost about two to three times as much as Astra's, despite its lower token prices, because it spends far more tokens reasoning. The clearer difference was reliability and speed: Astra delivered on all six attempts in minutes, while Carbon built two pages in five attempts.

When to Choose GPT-6.2 Astra vs. Gemini 4 Carbon

Which to choose: GPT-6.2 Astra for client deliverables and coding agents, Gemini 4 Carbon for cybersecurity, long inputs, and Google Cloud

The benchmarks are close, so the decision comes down to what you're building, how long you can wait, and whether Carbon's lower token price survives its longer reasoning.

Choose GPT-6.2 Astra if...

  • You produce client-ready documents and analysis, where Astra is slightly ahead on Agents' Last Exam and GDPval v2.
  • You run coding agents, where Astra leads FrontierCode 2.0 by about 3 points.
  • You need fast answers: Artificial Analysis measures Astra in minutes per task, Carbon in tens of minutes.
  • You need dependable results from long, open-ended build prompts, as in our test.

Choose Gemini 4 Carbon if...

  • You work in cybersecurity, where Carbon edges Astra on SEC-bench Pro and leads Google's exploit and patch benchmarks.
  • You reason over very long inputs, where Carbon scores 96.2% on GraphWalks at 256K to 1M tokens.
  • You deploy on Google Cloud: Carbon is listed on Vertex AI and in GitHub Copilot, while Astra isn't in the Copilot docs and we couldn't confirm it on Vertex AI.
  • Your tasks are short and token-light, where Carbon's lower rates win outright, especially before December 1.

How to Get Started With GPT-6.2 Astra and Gemini 4 Carbon

SurfaceGPT-6.2 AstraGemini 4 Carbon
Consumer appChatGPT Work and Codex (Plus, Pro, Enterprise, Edu)Gemini app and AI Mode in Search (Google AI Ultra only; Google AI Pro gets Argon)
First-party APIOpenAI APIGemini API in Google AI Studio (paid tier only)
Cloud platformsNot listed in the Azure AI Foundry docs as of November 18, 2026Google Vertex AI
Coding agentsCodex; not listed in the Cursor or GitHub Copilot docs as of November 18, 2026GitHub Copilot and Cursor; not listed in the Gemini CLI docs as of November 18, 2026
Third-party routersOpenRouterOpenRouter
API model IDgpt-6.2-astragemini-4-carbon

Carbon has the wider cloud reach through Google Cloud, while Astra is reached through OpenAI's own API and products. On OpenRouter, the two are a one-string swap:

from openai import OpenAI

client = OpenAI(base_url="https://openrouter.ai/api/v1")  # uses your OpenRouter key
response = client.chat.completions.create(
    model="openai/gpt-6.2-astra",  # or "google/gemini-4-carbon"
    messages=[{"role": "user", "content": "Summarize this contract..."}],
)
print(response.choices[0].message.content)

For full setups, see our Gemini 4 Carbon API tutorial and our GPT-6 Astra API tutorial.

Final Thoughts

On capability, GPT-6.2 Astra and Gemini 4 Carbon are close: Astra slightly ahead on professional work and coding, Carbon with the stronger evidence on the security and long-context work Google built it for.

In our hands-on test, the bigger gap was reliability and speed: Astra delivered every time in minutes, while Carbon built two pages in five attempts and needed a lower-effort setting to manage even that. I really did have to wait a while to get "Lanterns on Still Water." 

If you're keen to build with either model, I recommend checking out our Working with the OpenAI API and Practical AI with Google Gemini and NotebookLM courses.

Josef Waples

Author

Josef Waples

I'm a data science editor with contributions to research articles in scientific journals. I'm especially interested in linear algebra, statistics, R, and the like.

FAQs

Is GPT-6.2 Astra better than Gemini 4 Carbon?

Slightly, on the benchmarks both models appear in. On OpenAI's launch charts, GPT-6.2 Astra leads four of five shared benchmarks by 3.1 points or less, usually at a lower cost per task. Gemini 4 Carbon has the stronger published results for cybersecurity and very long inputs.

Is Gemini 4 Carbon cheaper than GPT-6.2 Astra?

Per token, yes: Carbon lists at $2 input and $10 output per million tokens through November 30, 2026, a quarter of Astra's $8 and $40, then $4 and $20. Per task, often not, because Carbon reasons for longer; on OpenAI's charts it costs more on three of four benchmarks.

Which is better for coding, GPT-6.2 Astra or Gemini 4 Carbon?

GPT-6.2 Astra has the edge on the one coding benchmark both appear in: 44.2% on FrontierCode 2.0 against 41.1% for Gemini 4 Carbon. Google reports strong coding results for Carbon too, but against the older GPT-6 Astra, so they don't settle the comparison with GPT-6.2.

Where can I use Gemini 4 Carbon and GPT-6.2 Astra?

Gemini 4 Carbon is in the paid tier of the Gemini API, on Google Vertex AI, in GitHub Copilot, and on OpenRouter. GPT-6.2 Astra is in the OpenAI API, ChatGPT Work, Codex, and OpenRouter. The API model IDs are gpt-6.2-astra and gemini-4-carbon.

Topics

Related