What is Transitive Dependency?

In databases, transitive dependency occurs when one attribute in a table depends on another attribute, which also depends on the primary key. Transitive dependency is a problem in database normalization because it leads to data issues, such as update, insertion, and deletion anomalies, which we will explore in this article. 

If, after this article, you would like to learn more, I recommend taking DataCamp’s Database Design course to familiarize yourself with relational databases and storing data in a database. I also recommend checking out our Normalization in SQL tutorial to learn about the normal forms in SQL, which is the most common language for managing relational databases in this context.

Understanding Transitive Dependency in Databases

In relational databases, transitive dependency occurs when one attribute indirectly depends on another through an intermediate attribute. This problem means that the value of one column can be determined indirectly from the values of two other columns. Consider the following table, called DataCamp_Programs:

From this table:

• Course_or_Skill_Track → Instructor: If we know the course or skill track, we know the instructor.

• Instructor does not → Course_or_Skill_Track: Sometimes, instructors teach more than one.

• Instructor → Instructor_Title: Each instructor has a title.

Therefore, Course_or_Skill_Track → Instructor_Title is a transitive dependency. 

Why Transitive Dependencies Cause Issues

Transitive dependencies can cause database issues, primarily related to data redundancy, anomalies, and inconsistency.

Data redundancy

Data redundancy occurs when the same data is unnecessarily repeated across the database, leading to inefficiencies. In the example of the DataCamp_Programs table, the instructor’s title is stored multiple times for each course they teach. This repetition wastes storage space and makes the database harder to maintain.

Data anomalies

Let's now look at update, insertion, and deletion issues.

Update anomalies

Update anomalies occur when changes to data must be applied in multiple places due to redundancy. This leads to inconsistencies if some instances are updated while others are overlooked. Imagine, for example, that we used a SQL query to update the DataCamp_Programs table because Mona Khalil’s title has changed to Lead Data Scientist. You would need to manually update each row where her title appears. If even one instance is missed, the database will contain conflicting information about her current title. 

Insertion anomalies

Insertion anomalies occur when you cannot insert data into the database because other required data is missing. In other cases, you might be able to insert data but the structure of the table forces you to include irrelevant, redundant, or missing information, such as in the example below:

Deletion anomalies

Deletion anomalies occur when deleting a record inadvertently removes valuable information from the database. For example, deleting the record that contains Izzy Weber would remove the instructor title as well, which could lead to data loss, as you might no longer have the full range of titles in the system. Here, we may have removed Data Coach from the system entirely without intending that behavior.

Removing Transitive Dependencies with 3NF

In the database context, normalization organizes the data to minimize redundancy and improve data integrity. For this reason, transitive dependencies are often discussed in the context of third normal form (3NF), a database normalization technique that eliminates dependencies to address the problem of transitive dependency. 

The third normal form is a level of database normalization that eliminates transitive dependencies and ensures that every non-key attribute depends only on the primary key. This helps prevent redundancy and the errors caused by transitive dependencies. Consider the following steps when normalizing a database schema.

Identifying transitive dependencies

To spot transitive dependencies in your database, break the process down:

1. Check Functional Dependencies on the Primary Key: Start by identifying all functional dependencies where attributes rely directly on the primary key. This step helps you focus on the main relationships in your table.
2. Look for Indirect Dependencies: Next, check if any non-key attributes (those not part of the primary key) depend on other non-key attributes. If you find that one non-key attribute relies on another, which itself depends on the primary key, you’ve identified a transitive dependency.
3. Test for Redundancy or Anomalies: Finally, think about whether this indirect dependency introduces data redundancy or makes updates more complicated.

Splitting tables

Once you have identified the transitive dependencies, you need to split the tables to eliminate them. You will split the table into smaller tables where non-key attributes depend directly on the primary key. You will also preserve the relationship between the tables by linking through foreign keys.

Here’s how you might split the DataCamp_Programs table into two tables to normalize it and eliminate the transitive dependency. As you will see, we split the table into two. instructor becomes the key to link the two.   

Table 1: courses_table

Table 1: instructors_table

How to Avoid Transitive Dependencies

When designing your database, it is important to avoid transitive dependencies to maintain data efficiency, scalability, and integrity. The following are best practices to minimize the risks of redundancy, anomalies, and inconsistency.

• Normalization During Schema Design: If you are designing your database from the schema, it is important to consider the third normal form (3NF) in the early stages. This approach will help reduce transitive dependency by applying the normalization technique. 

• Regular Schema Audits: After creating your database, it is important to conduct regular audits to ensure it remains free of transitive dependencies.

• Avoiding Oversimplifying Relationships: Always map the relationships and separate the entities properly in different tables to store different information.

Conclusion

Transitive dependencies in databases occur when an attribute in a table depends on another attribute, which depends on the primary key. Transitive dependency always impacts database efficiency by introducing redundancy, inconsistencies, and anomalies. As a developer, it is important to identify and eliminate transitive dependencies for data integrity. You should also identify and eliminate the transitive dependencies during database design. Achieving the third normal form (3NF) will help you optimize the databases and improve efficiency.

If you want to improve your database design skills, I recommend taking DataCamp’s Creating PostgreSQL Databases course to learn more about schema design and database access controls. Finally, if you are looking to advance your database management skills for big data, I recommend taking our Introduction to Data Modeling in Snowflake course to learn more about relationships, dimensional modeling, and data vaults to craft efficient cloud data warehouses.